Magisk is a tool that allows you to root your Android device without modifying the system partition. This means that you can install Magisk on your device and still receive updates from your manufacturer without any issues.
Magisk also includes a module system that allows you to install additional modifications to your devices, such as custom ROMs, kernels, and mods.
TWRP (Team Win Recovery Project) is a custom recovery for Android devices. It allows you to perform advanced tasks such as flashing custom ROMs, kernels, and mods, as well as creating and restoring backups.
TWRP is a more powerful tool than Magisk, but it can also be more risky to use, as it has the potential to brick your device if used improperly.
Magisk Vs TWRP
Differences between Magisk and TWRP
| Parameter | Magisk | TWRP |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Magisk is an open-source rooting and modification tool that allows users to root their Android devices and install custom ROMs, kernels, and mods. | TWRP is a custom recovery tool that allows users to install custom ROMs, kernels, and other mods, as well as perform advanced tasks such as backing up and restoring the device. |
| Installation | Magisk can be installed via a boot image patch, a Magisk Manager app, or through TWRP. | TWRP must be installed as a custom recovery image through fastboot or another flashing tool. |
| Compatibility | Magisk is compatible with most Android devices and can be installed on both rooted and unrooted devices. | TWRP is compatible with a wide range of Android devices, but may not be available for all devices. |
| Rooting | Magisk can root a device by installing a modified boot image and Magisk Manager app. | TWRP does not root a device on its own, but it can be used to flash a rooting package such as SuperSU. |
| Custom ROMs | Magisk can be used to install custom ROMs on a rooted device. | TWRP can be used to install custom ROMs on a rooted device. |
| Custom Kernels | Magisk can be used to install custom kernels on a rooted device. | TWRP can be used to install custom kernels on a rooted device. |
| Modules | Magisk has a built-in system for installing and managing “Modules,” which are small apps that add features or functionality to the device. | TWRP does not have a built-in system for installing and managing modules. |
| Systemless Root | Magisk uses a “systemless” root method that allows it to hide the root status of a device from certain apps and services. | TWRP does not have a systemless root feature. |
| SafetyNet | Magisk can bypass Google’s SafetyNet system, which is used to detect rooted devices and block certain apps and services. | TWRP does not have a feature to bypass SafetyNet. |
| Updating | Magisk can be easily updated through the Magisk Manager app. | TWRP must be manually updated by flashing the latest version through fastboot or another flashing tool. |
| Backup and Restore | Magisk does not have a built-in backup and restore feature. | TWRP has a built-in backup and restore feature that allows users to create and restore backups of their device’s partitions. |
| Recovery Mode | Magisk does not have its own recovery mode. | TWRP has its own recovery mode that can be accessed by pressing specific buttons during boot. |
| User Interface | Magisk Manager has a user-friendly interface that is easy to use for beginners. | TWRP has a more advanced interface that may be intimidating for some users. |
| Customization | Magisk allows for a wide range of customization options through its modules and systemless root feature. | TWRP allows for less customization, but has a built-in theme engine that allows users to customize the look of the recovery. |
| Development | Magisk is actively developed and maintained by a team of developers. | TWRP is actively developed and maintained by a team of developers. |
In summary, Magisk and TWRP are both powerful tools that allow users to customize and modify their Android devices.
However, they have some key differences in terms of installation, compatibility, rooting, custom ROMs and kernels, modules, systemless root, SafetyNet, updating, backup and restore, recovery mode, user interface, and customization.
Magisk is generally considered to be more user-friendly and offers more customization options, while TWRP is more advanced and has a built-in backup and restore feature. Both tools are actively developed and maintained by teams of developers.
Ultimately, the choice between Magisk and TWRP will depend on the specific needs and preferences of the user.